While Episcopalians argue, South African Anglicans celebrate priest's birthday
Elliott Sylvester | August 11, 2003
CAPE TOWN - While U.S. Episcopalians fight back protests over the approval of the church's first openly gay bishop, the Very Rev. Rowan Smith, the openly gay leader of one of South Africa's oldest Anglican parishes, happily cut a cake Sunday as a 150 parishioners sang "Happy Birthday" to him.
Though Smith, dean of the Cathedral Church of St. George the Martyr in Cape Town, shocked the church when he announced his homosexuality from the pulpit about five years ago, many of his doring parishioners have learned to accept his sexual identity, they say.
"I don't care about gay, gay, gay like everyone is saying. He is a good man who comes to see me in hospital when I am sick. We love him here," Ludmilla Dolganova, 80, said clutching a string tied to
a bobbing green balloon at Smith's 60th birthday party.
Meanwhile, the Episcopal Church - the U.S branch of the Anglican
church -is struggling to cope with the confirmation Tuesday of
Bishop-elect V. Gene Robinson of New Hampshire, who is gay.
Several conservative diocese in the United States are
investigating how they can divorce themselves from the national
Anglican bishops in Africa, Asia and Latin America have
condemned the confirmation, and some threatened to sever ties with
the U.S. church.
The Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams has called an
emergency meeting for October of the world's Anglican leaders to
discuss Robinson's confirmation.
Standing in the small cathedral hall in rainy Cape Town, Smith
and his congregants argue that his homosexuality has no bearing on
his role as a religious leader.
"This cathedral is an icon of unity to the greater community,"
he said, standing in the gray, stone building, surrounded by
stained glass windows. "I like to think that that is its appeal,
ahead of people seeing my sexuality first."
Smith, who joined the clergy 35 years ago, said he always knew
he was gay, but did not talk about it when he was younger out of
fear of his family's reaction.
As he got older, he spoke more openly about his sexuality to the
gay community, but he did not discuss it with parishioners.
When he was named Dean of Cape Town about seven years ago, a
high profile position in the church here, he re-evaluated his
decision. About five years ago, he took to the pulpit and told his
parishioners he was gay.
Many were shocked, much like his family was when he told them.
But they learned to accept him, Smith said, and it may have brought
him even closer to his flock.
"It is common for women to hug you when leaving church, but now
I find more men reaching out for that hug as well," he said. "It is
a sign that we accept each other as people, as human beings."
Archbishop Njongonkulu Ndungane, head of the South African
church, accepts him as well.
"The sexual orientation of a person is not relevant," he told a
news conference Tuesday, singling out Smith as an example.
However, Ndungane said, homosexual clergy must be celibate, a
rule Smith says he follows.
Since revealing his orientation, Smith has caused controversy.
Three years ago, he appeared in print and television ads for a
gay and lesbian film festival wearing a full cassock with a red
devil's tail sticking out the back.
"People say homosexuals are the devil's spawn," the caption
read. "I don't believe it."
Smith said it was his way of fighting stereotypes that
homosexuals are evil. He survived the public outcry for his
expulsion after apologizing to the church.
He has also joined AIDS activists in their bid to secure state
funding to treat people infected with HIV, a position shared by
Ndungane and many other religious leaders here.
Smith's progressive beliefs were evident throughout the
In one corner, a wooden statue of a black Madonna holds an
infant surrounded by candles. Bible readings are delivered in three
of the country's official languages. English, Afrikaans and Xhosa,
an indigenous black language.
Smith's character and beliefs are far more important than his
homosexuality, Elise Van Wyk, 49, said as she helped celebrate
Smith's birthday, which fell on Friday.
"He manages to break barriers of class, race, denomination, clan
and sex with his sense of humor and inspiring love and humanity,"
she said. "Why people like him and accept him is because he is not
just a gay man trying to do God's work. He is so much more than his
Though many African bishops have expressed disgust at Robinson's
appointment in the United States, Smith said he does not believe a
similar furor will erupt in South Africa.
"Under apartheid we realized what discrimination really is and
saw it in all its forms. Our culture of human rights here is much
stronger and perhaps our society is more open minded than those
people debating this matter in the United States," Smith said.
"We learned not to judge. The church said this under apartheid
about race and maybe they need to say it again now in this debate
on sexuality," he said. -Sapa-AP
Ugandan Anglicans to cut links with US gay bishop's diocese
British gay bishop's approval threatens Anglican communion split
UK Archbishop urges care after gay US bishop appointment
Cape Town Anglican archbishop calls for dialogue on gay bishop